A Study in Scarlet

A Study in Scarlet

Book - 2001
Average Rating:
Rate this:
13
1

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's A Study in Scarlet is the literary debut of the world's most famous fictional detective, Sherlock Holmes, introduced by Iain Sinclair with notes by Ed Glinert in Penguin Classics.

Convalescing in London after a disastrous experience of war in Afghanistan, Dr John Watson finds himself sharing rooms with his enigmatic new acquaintance, Sherlock Holmes. But their quiet bachelor life at 221B Baker Street is soon interrupted by the grisly discovery of a dead man in a grimy 'ill-omened' house in south-east London, his face contorted by an expression of horror and hatred such as Watson has never seen before. On the wall, the word rache - German for 'revenge' - is written in blood, yet there are no wounds on the victim or signs of a struggle. Watson's head is in a whirl, but the formidable Holmes relishes this challenge to his deductive powers, and so begins their famous investigative partnership.

In his introduction, Iain Sinclair discusses the links between Sherlock Holmes mysteries and the Jack the Ripper murders, Conan Doyle's narrative style and his depiction of London. This edition also includes further reading, a chronology and notes.

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (1859-1930) was born in Edinburgh where he qualified as a doctor, but it was his writing which brought him fame, with the creation of Sherlock Holmes, the first scientific detective. He was also a social reformer who used his investigative skills to prove the innocence of individuals.

Iain Sinclair is the author of Downriver (winner of the James Tait Black Memorial Prize and the Encore Award), and his latest book Ghost Milk: Calling Time on the Grand Project is published by Penguin.

Ed Glinert writes a regular column for Time Out magazine, and is the author of The Literary Guide to London . Glinert's latest book, The London Compendium , is published by Penguin.

If you liked A Study in Scarlet you might enjoy The Hound of the Baskervilles , also available in Penguin Classics.

Publisher: London : Penguin Books, 2001.
ISBN: 9780140439083
Branch Call Number: Doyle
Characteristics: xxix, 143 pages ; 20 cm.
Additional Contributors: Glinert, Ed
Sinclair, Iain 1943-- Author

Opinion

From the critics


Community Activity

Comment

Add a Comment
k
Katie_Dublin
Jul 20, 2019

Fantastic introduction to the greatest detective duo in history. I was a little surprised when the mystery was solved about halfway through. The book then jumps back in time to give a first hand account of all the events leading to the crime. However, I found this part just as intriguing as Holmes' deduction, and particularly enjoyed the role of Mormonism.

b
blue_dog_17792
Jun 01, 2019

Great book, very interesting.

k
kwylie04
Mar 27, 2019

I agree that A Study in Scarlet is not the best of the Holmes stories, but I still think it does a very good job in introducing the worldwide phenomenon that is Sherlock Holmes. Learning from the point of view of Dr. Watson how Holmes' practice began and Watson learning how Holmes worked are all written superbly.

Granted, the inserting of the backstory about what brought the villain to the point he was when he faced off with Holmes is kind of jarring. The first time I read it, I was so confused as to where I'd just been taken. But if you keep going, you'll find that the villain's story is actually rather interesting, and sheds much light on his actions in London.

A great story.

h
Havanacat
Dec 28, 2018

The first introduction to the classic detective, Sherlock Holmes.

a
Andrew Kyle Bacon
May 07, 2018

It's so strange, this being the first Holmes story, as it is wholly underwhelming. I am glad, however, that it establishes one of the finest literary characters conceived, and introduced the world to the World's Greatest Detective. Yet the book is strange, featuring a very odd structure in its second half, which mars the book, although not perhaps as much as other reviewers would lead you to believe. The first half of the novel, where Holmes undertakes the investigation proper, is enthralling and engaging, but the second half of the novel, which follows three characters who become entwined with Brigham Young (yes, that Brigham Young) and the settling of Utah. It's such a strange turn, and feels like such a swift tonal shift that it seems wrong. Suddenly, we are gone from the streets of London and have turned to the Prairie and the desert. Suddenly our detective novel turns to a western novel, and the change is so peculiar that it might leave you scratching your head. That is, until you see exactly what Doyle is doing. He shifts the narrative from Dr. Watson's account of the case, a subjective telling from his perspective of how Holmes works, to an "objective," historical narrative accounting for the events leading up to the crime. It also reveals how strong of a writer Doyle was, since in his attempt to switch settings he switches genres as well, molding his style to fit the landscape in which he writes.

Is A Study in Scarlet the best of the Holmes' stories which I've read? Not by any chance! But is it a bad novella on its own? By no means. In fact, it's so short and engaging, I wonder why anyone would begrudge it and not wish to read it to completion. It's not bad by any means, it just doesn't quite fit with what we expect a Holmes story to be like. But, to be very fair, The Hound of the Baskervilles is also a very strange novel. Perhaps our perception of what a Holmes story is like is shaped more by movies and TV than we think? Perhaps these stories seem odd to readers because they view Holmes through the lens of how he has been presented, not by his creator, but by his interpreters. Perhaps, just perhaps, the reason we react to these stories and find them so odd, is because we don't exactly know who Sherlock Holmes is because we've never read him. I'm finding that to be the case with me.

s
SPPL_Anna
Mar 19, 2018

Let's just talk about how suddenly the narrative jumps back to follow the Mormons out in Utah and how absolutely buckwild that is as a premise for a murder in the 1880s.

g
gogo12127
Dec 17, 2017

In 1887, a young Arthur Conan Doyle published A Study in Scarlet, creating an international icon in the quick-witted sleuth Sherlock Holmes. In this first Holmes mystery, the detective introduces himself to Dr. John H. Watson with the puzzling line, “You have been in Afghanistan, I perceive,” and begins Watson's, and the world's, fascination with this enigmatic character. In A Study in Scarlet, Doyle presents two equally perplexing mysteries for Holmes to solve: one a murder that takes place in the shadowy outskirts of London in a locked room where the haunting word Rache is written upon the wall; the other a kidnapping set in the American West. Picking up the “scarlet thread of murder running through the colourless skein of life,” Holmes demonstrates his uncanny knack for finding the truth, tapping into powers of deduction that will captivate readers today. (Description slightly edited from the synopsis on the back cover of this paperback edition, a synopsis presumably provided by the publisher – The Modern Library.)

This first Sherlock Holmes mystery is the first Sherlock Holmes mystery I've read. It's a rather old-fashioned mystery with old-fashioned values. As Anne Perry notes in her introduction to this Modern Library edition, “Conan Doyle's characters are essentially Victorian, with the strengths and weaknesses of their time, and probably of Conan Doyle himself. . . . His convictions and opinions were of his time and place. His values were the admiration of honor, intelligence, reason, loyalty, fortitude, invention, and optimism. He seems to have understood women little. . . . He had instinctive prejudices against certain groups of people. His reference to Jews is pejorative, and his portrayal of Mormons in this story is a gross distortion.

Despite my misgivings of this first Sherlock Holmes mystery, I plan to continue to read the other Sherlock Holmes novels.

i
im_not_a_nerd
Jun 24, 2016

I meant to give it a 5/5, however I mis-clicked and accidentally rated it 4.5/5. Now I cannot change it. OPL plz fix.

m
modestgoddess
Oct 10, 2015

This is where the Sherlock saga begins....It left me underwhelmed. I much preferred the treatment the BBC "Sherlock" TV series gave this story. As a previous reviewer mentions, the chunk set in Utah is really not that interesting. This being said, if you want a good read of some Sherlock stories, borrow The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes instead. Some well-known cases in there and much more engagingly written.

g
Gobookworm
Sep 02, 2015

This is probably the BEST book I have ever read!!! The plot twists and turns and keeps you on the hook, and the characters are delightful and unique! A+++ book!!!!

View All Comments

Age Suitability

Add Age Suitability
b
blue_dog_17792
May 28, 2019

blue_dog_17792 thinks this title is suitable for 11 years and over

Summary

Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.

Notices

Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.

Quotes

Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number

Recommendations

Subject Headings

  Loading...

Find it at VPL

  Loading...
[]
[]
To Top